Skip to product information
1 of 1
This recipe was developed especially for us and can truly be called the ultimate key lime pie. Made from scratch using simple ingredients,it features a tangy key lime custard baked in a traditional graham cracker crust. This is the real deal—sweet, sour, and utterly sublime.

Key Lime Pie

Item #: A-513

In stock
Regular price $59.95
Regular price Sale price $59.95
On Sale Sold out
Pre-sliced to serve 12
10" pie
Thaw & Serve
Qty
Pre-sliced to serve 12
10" pie
Thaw & Serve
This recipe was developed especially for us and can truly be called the ultimate key lime pie. Made from scratch using simple ingredients,it features a tangy key lime custard baked in a traditional graham cracker crust. This is the real deal—sweet, sour, and utterly sublime.
View full details

Key Lime Pie

Regular price $59.95
Regular price Sale price $59.95
On Sale Sold out

Reviews

Based on 83 reviews
Write Review
Clear Filters
Order By
Newest First
Oldest First
Most Popular
Highest Rating
Reviews With
Any Media
Images
Videos
Breakdown
62
7
8
2
4
Verified Customer
Vicky S
I recommend this product
Key Lime Pie
Some of the best Key Lime pie I’ve had! Really good.
Was this review helpful?
Yes
Report
Share
2 months ago
Verified Customer
Bill
Philadelphia, US
I recommend this product
Key Lime Pie
Good Key Lime taste. Crust could be more buttery; mine was a bit dry.
Was this review helpful?
Yes
Report
Share
3 months ago
Verified Customer
Patricia
Newark, United States
I recommend this product
Key Lime Pie
delicious. creamy and tasrt/sweet
Reply:
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. We look forward to helping you again!
Was this review helpful?
Yes
Report
Share
4 months ago
Verified Customer
Christine
Spokane, United States
Key Lime Pie
Not as good as it used to be.
Was this review helpful?
Yes
Report
Share
6 months ago
Verified Customer
Jeanne
I recommend this product
Key Lime Pie
Products excellent but ordering very difficult especially if you use a gift card.
Was this review helpful?
Yes
Report
Share
6 months ago
Verified Customer
Wanda
Utopia, United States
I recommend this product
Key Lime Pie
I always get one of these! So impressive to pull out of the fridge for guests!
Was this review helpful?
Yes
Report
Share
7 months ago
Verified Customer
Lynn
I recommend this product
Key Lime Pie
Good taste, but not as lime tasting and tart as expected..
Reply:
Thank you for your thoughtful review, Lynn! We appreciate your feedback on the taste as it helps us to improve. We hope to have the chance to help you again soon!
Was this review helpful?
Yes
Report
Share
7 months ago
Verified Customer
Barbara
Key Lime Pie
It was attractive and delicious! The only dessert I serve that I didn’t make myself.
Reply:
Thank you for taking the time to leave a great review, Barbara. We aim to delight our customers with every product we offer, and it's great to hear that our Key Lime Pie exceeded your expectations. We look forward to helping you again soon!
Was this review helpful?
Yes
Report
Share
7 months ago
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

New content loaded